Shoe Size 9

Women's Gently Used Shoes Size 9 and 9.5 – Style, Comfort & Value

Step into savings with our collection of Women's Gently Used Shoes Size 9 and 9.5. Whether you're searching for chic heels, comfy flats, trendy sneakers, or classic boots, you'll find top brands in excellent condition—all at unbeatable consignment prices.

Each pair in our Women's Gently Used Shoes Size 9 and 9.5 category is carefully selected for quality and style, offering the perfect blend of fashion and function. From casual favorites to dressy must-haves, we have the right fit for your lifestyle.

Shop Women's Gently Used Shoes Size 9 and 9.5 today and give your wardrobe a fresh step forward—stylishly and sustainably.

    $
    -
    $
Toms Tan Suede Booties Size 9 with side zippers and wedge heels, displayed on a wooden floor. Stylish ankle boots ideal for casual wear.
On sale

Toms Tan Suede Pre-Owned Ladies Booties - Size 9

$19.99 $44.99
Toms Brown Suede Wedges Size 9 with lace-up front and closed toe, featuring a soft suede finish and wedge heel for casual or dressy wear.

Toms Brown Suede Pre-Owned Ladies Wedge Booties - Size 9

$27.99
Clarks Black Suede Booties Size 9 with elastic side panels and wooden soles, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments.
On sale

Clarks Black Suede Pre-Owned Ladies Booties - Size 9

$24.99 $54.99
Boc Shoe Tan Suede Booties Size 9.5 with stacked heel and side zipper, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. Soft suede finish ideal for fall fashion.
On sale

Boc Tan Suede Pre-Owned Ladies Booties - Size 9.5

$15.99 $19.99
B.O.C. tan wedge sandals in size 9 with crisscross leather straps and side buckle, pre-owned casual comfort style for women.

Boc Tan Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Wedge Sandals - Size 9

$29.99
Bandolino Wedge Sandals in tan with faux crocodile texture and cork wedge heel, pre-owned size 9 for casual everyday wear.

Bandolino Tan Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Wedge Sandals - Size 9

$26.99
Coach Gold Solid Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 9.5 with cork wedge heel and metallic leather straps, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments.
On sale

Coach Gold Solid Ladies Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 9.5

$39.99 $47.99
Talbots Shoe Red Suede Heel Size 9.5 with almond toe and stiletto heel, featured at Margaret's Fine Consignments. Elegant red suede finish for formal wear.
On sale

Talbots Red Suede Pre-Owned Ladies Heel - Size 9.5

$12.99 $17.99
Charles David Black/White Polka Dot Pre-Owned Heel - Size 9.5

Charles David Black/White Polka Dot Pre-Owned Heel - Size 9.5

$44.99
Not Rated Sandals Size 9 with blush pink straps and rhinestone lace detail, new with tags at Margaret’s Fine Consignments.

Not Rated Blush Rhinestone Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 9

$24.99
Louise et Cie Sandals Size 9.5 with snake-print straps in brown and tan, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. Stylish pre-owned casual footwear.

Louise et Cie Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 9.5

$36.99
Kate Spade Sandals Size 9.5 in black leather with silver studs and jute soles, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. New with tags, unworn.

Kate Spade Black Studded Pre-Owned Ladies Sandals - Size 9.5

$59.99
Dream Pairs Sandals 9.5 - Red Espadrille Shoes with closed toe and jute wedge heel, featuring ankle wrap straps for a chic summer look.

Dream Pairs Sandals Size 9.5

$24.99
Pelle Moda Heels - Blush Solid Heels Size 9.5 with ankle strap and stiletto heel, ideal for women's formal wear or special occasions.

Pelle Moda Heel Size 9.5

$34.99
Sam Edelman blue heels size 9.5 with ankle strap and suede finish, featured at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. Elegant stiletto perfect for formal wear.

Sam Edelman Heel Size 9.5

$34.99
Patrizia Sandals Size 9 with turquoise floral straps and wedge heel, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. Pre-owned summer footwear.

Patrizia Sandals Size 9

$21.99

Recently viewed