Age Check

Please verify your age to continue.

Item has been added

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

  • Real Style. Real Deals.

New With Tags: Just In

Shop brand-new, never-worn pieces with original tags—exclusive finds at consignment prices, only at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. Styles this good don’t last long!

American Eagle Blue/Red Denim Pre-Owned New With Tags Sandals - Size 7

$19.99

american eagle

Frye Tan Textured Pre-Owned New With Tags Sandals - Size 7.5

$64.99

Frye

Loft Gray Solid New with Tag Pre-Owned Top - Size Small featuring long sleeves and layered hem, ideal for casual winter wear at Margaret's.

Loft Gray Solid New with Tag Pre-Owned Top - Size Small

$25.99

loft

Ann Taylor Cream Bow Top - Size XS, sleeveless and fitted with front bow detail, perfect for summer casual wear, new with tags.
Front view of Ann Taylor Cream Bow Top - Size XS on mannequin, featuring a large decorative bow and scoop neckline, new with tags.

Ann Taylor Cream Bow New with Tags Pre-Owned Top - Size XS

$19.99

Ann Taylor

J Crew Pink/White Checkered Pre-Owned Ladies Casual Top - Size XS shown on model, sleeveless button-down perfect for summer wear.
Front view of J Crew Pink/White Checkered Pre-Owned Ladies Casual Top - Size XS on mannequin, sleeveless with collared neckline.

J Crew Pink/White Checkered Pre-Owned Ladies Casual Top - Size XS

$22.99

J Crew

Knox Rose Cream Sheer Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium with circular embroidery, sleeveless design, and keyhole neckline, ideal for summer wear.
Front view of Knox Rose Cream Sheer Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium displayed on mannequin, featuring flowy hem and embroidered sheer overlay.

Knox Rose Cream Sheer Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium

$16.99

Knox Rose

Jantzen Teal/Multi Print New With Tags Swimsuit - Size 10 modeled front view, featuring vibrant tropical pattern and ruched neckline.
Front view of Jantzen Teal/Multi Print Swimsuit - Size 10 on mannequin, showcasing colorful abstract design and gathered neckline.

Jantzen Teal/Multi Print New With Tags Swimsuit - Size 10

$24.99

Jantzen

Rachel Roy Pink Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size 8 featuring a sleeveless asymmetric neckline and knee-length tailored fit.

Rachel Roy Pink Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size 8

$29.99

Rachel Roy

Fantaist Navy/White Floral Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size Medium featuring sleeveless design, keyhole neckline, and bold floral-stripe pattern.

Fantaist Navy/White Floral Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size Medium

$29.99

Fantaist

Charles David Black/White Polka Dot Pre-Owned Heel Size 9.5 with pointed toe and kitten heel, ideal for dressy occasions or vintage-inspired outfits.

Charles David Black/White Polka Dot Pre-Owned Heel - Size 9.5

$44.99

Charles David

Blank Green Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Top - Size Large with lace detailing and long sleeves, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments.

Blank Green Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Top - Size Large

$30.99

Blank

Cole Haan White Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Heel - Size 8 featuring a classic block heel and pointed toe, ideal for formal or office wear.

Cole Haan White Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Heel - Size 8

$44.99

Cole Haan

View all

Fresh Finds: Shop New Arrivals

Discover the latest pre-loved styles and new-with-tags treasures just added to Margaret’s Fine Consignments. Updated daily—shop them before they’re gone!

American Eagle Blue/Red Denim Pre-Owned New With Tags Sandals - Size 7

$19.99

american eagle

Dooney & Bourke Brown Logo Pre-Owned Card Holder

$17.99

Dooney & Bourke

Fun Paper Cream/Blue Pre-Owned Beach Bag

$15.99

Fun Paper

Brahmin Yellow/Green Pineapple Pre-Owned Purse

$165.99

brahmin

Brahmin White Crocodile Pre-Owned Wallet

$69.99

brahmin

Frye Tan Textured Pre-Owned New With Tags Sandals - Size 7.5

$64.99

Frye

Loft Black Solid Romper - Size Medium Petite with short sleeves and drawstring waist, displayed on mannequin front view.

Loft Black Solid Romper - Size Medium Petite

$21.99

loft

Halston Coral Solid Pre-Owned Top in Size XS with flutter sleeves and ruffle neckline, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments. A vibrant summer casual top.
Halston Coral Solid Pre-Owned Top in size XS with ruffled neckline and short sleeves, available at Margaret’s Fine Consignments.

Halston Coral Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size XS

$26.99

Halston

Front view of Hidden White Solid Pre-Owned Jeans - Size 4 with classic five-pocket design and straight leg fit, available at Margaret’s.

Hidden White Solid Pre-Owned Jeans - Size 4

$26.99

Hidden

Joy Joy Pink Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size Small with tiered design and puff sleeves, available at Margaret's for casual or dressy wear.

Joy Joy Pink Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size Small

$21.99

joy joy

Sondra Roberts Black/White Print Purse with geometric tribal pattern and pom-pom trim, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments.

Sondra Roberts Black/White Print Purse

$29.99

Sondra Roberts

Alexis Green Print Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium with puff sleeves and ruffled hem, displayed on mannequin front view.

Alexis Green Print Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium

$29.99

Alexis

View all

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

  • Real Savings!

Shop Dresses by Size

Timeless Style, Secondhand Prices

Shop Dresses By Style

Dresses for Every Occasion

rom casual to cocktail, explore our curated collection of gently used and new-with-tags dresses at Margaret’s Fine Consignments—style, value, and sustainability in every stitch.

Fashion Blue Corduroy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL

$22.99

fashion

A New Day Burgundy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL with long sleeves and relaxed fit, ideal for winter or cocktail wear. Gently used and sustainable.

A New Day Burgandy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL

$22.99

A New Day

Loft Gray/Black Polka Dot Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium shown on model with front tie detail and long sleeves, ideal for casual winter wear.
Loft Gray/Black Polka Dot Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium displayed on mannequin, featuring front tie waist and subtle polka dot pattern.

Loft Gray/Black Polka Dot Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium

$15.99 $26.99

loft

Talbots Black Solid Pre-Owned Dress - Size 10 modeled with 3/4 sleeves and gathered waist, ideal for elegant everyday wear.
Talbots Black Solid Pre-Owned Dress - Size 10 displayed on mannequin, featuring V-neckline and smocked waist for a flattering fit.

Talbots Black Solid Pre-Owned Dress- Size 10

$24.99

Talbots

DKNY Burnt Orange Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL modeled on a plus-size woman, sleeveless with a relaxed fit and scoop neckline.
Front view of DKNY Burnt Orange Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL on mannequin, showcasing sleeveless design and flowy silhouette.

DKNY Burnt Orange Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL

$24.99

DKNY

Tommy Hilfiger Red/Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL modeled, featuring lace-up neckline and short sleeves. Available at Margaret's Consignments.
Front view of Tommy Hilfiger Red/Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL on mannequin, showcasing casual A-line silhouette and lace-up detail.

Tommy Hilfiger Red/Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL

$15.99 $22.99

Tommy Hilfiger

Ralph Lauren Sport Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL modeled on a woman, featuring a polo collar and short sleeves for casual elegance.
Front view of Ralph Lauren Sport Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL on mannequin, showcasing button placket and relaxed fit.

Ralph Lauren Sport Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size XL

$26.99

ralph lauren sport

J Crew Blue Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Dress - Size 0 Petite styled on model, featuring ruffle detail and short sleeves for a casual chic look.
Front view of J Crew Blue Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Dress - Size 0 Petite on mannequin, showcasing ruffled yoke and relaxed fit.

J Crew Blue Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Dress - Size 0 Petite

$24.99

J Crew

Moda International Red Pre-Owned Dress - Size 10 with deep V-neck and front tie detail, ideal for cocktail events. Available now at Margaret's.

Moda International Red Pre-Owned Dress - Size 10

$24.99 $36.99

moda international

Gap Tan/Black Animal Print Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium with long sleeves and tiered mini hem, perfect for casual or winter wear.

Gap Tan/Black Animal Print Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium

$22.99 $31.99

Gap

Chico Black/Gold Print Size 10 Pre-Owned Dress with zigzag pattern front and solid black sleeves, ideal for cocktail events. Gently used.

Chico Black/Gold Print Pre-Owned Dress - Size 10

$26.99 $39.99

chico

Kate Spade Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size 8 with sleeveless design and front notch neckline, available at Margaret's Fine Consignment.

Kate Spade Navy Pre-Owned Dress - Size 8

$64.99 $89.99

Kate Spade

Rachel Roy Pink Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size 8 featuring a sleeveless asymmetric neckline and knee-length tailored fit.

Rachel Roy Pink Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size 8

$29.99

Rachel Roy

IC by Connie K blue pre-owned dress in size medium with sheer stripe accents on sleeves and hem, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments.

IC by Connie K Blue Solid Pre-Owned Dress - Size Medium

$23.99

IC by connie k

Fantaist Navy/White Floral Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size Medium featuring sleeveless design, keyhole neckline, and bold floral-stripe pattern.

Fantaist Navy/White Floral Pre-Owned New With Tags Dress - Size Medium

$29.99

Fantaist

Evan Picone Blue/Multi Floral Pre-Owned Dress - Size 8 with sleeveless halter neckline and ruched waist, ideal for spring or summer events.

Evan Picone Blue/Multi Floral Pre-Owned Dress - Size 8

$24.99

Evan Picone

View all

Margaret's Tops

Everyday Style, Secondhand Savings

Shop Tops by Style

Stylish Tops for Every Day

Browse our collection of gently used and new-with-tags tops at Margaret’s Fine Consignments—perfect for dressing up, layering, or keeping it casual in sustainable style.

Ralph Lauren White/Black Stripe Pre-Owned Casual Top - Size Small

$21.99

Ralph Lauren

Black/Orange/Pink Print Pre-Owned Shrug - Size One Size Fits Most

$21.99

No Brand

Ann Taylor Green Solid Shrug - Size Medium

$24.99

Ann Taylor

Loft Blue Lace Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium

$19.99

loft

Loft Black/White Stripe Pre-Owned Top - Size XS

$21.99

loft

Ann Taylor Black Solid Pre-Owned Shrug - Size Large

$22.99

Ann Taylor

Ann Taylor Charcoal Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size Small

$22.99

Ann Taylor

Madewell Black Pre-Owned Blouse - Size XS

$19.99

Madewell

Loft Red Pre-Owned Blouse - Size Small

$20.99

loft

Ann Taylor Olive Pre-Owned Blouse - Size Small with deep V-neck wrap front and long sleeves, ideal for winter layering or office wear.

Ann Taylor Olive Pre-Owned Blouse - Size Small

$26.99

Ann Taylor

Ann Taylor Navy Pre-Owned Blouse - Size Small with draped front design and long sleeves, ideal for winter wear. Gently used and stylish.

Ann Taylor Navy Pre-Owned Blouse - Size Small

$22.99

Ann Taylor

Loft Gray Solid New with Tag Pre-Owned Top - Size Small featuring long sleeves and layered hem, ideal for casual winter wear at Margaret's.

Loft Gray Solid New with Tag Pre-Owned Top - Size Small

$25.99

loft

Ann Taylor Gold Textured Pre-Owned Top - Size Large with long sleeves and scoop neckline, ideal for evening wear or upscale casual looks.

Ann Taylor Gold Textured Pre-Owned Top - Size Large

$22.99

Ann Taylor

J Crew Black Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size XS styled on model with long sleeves and wide collar, ideal for casual winter wear.
Front view of J Crew Black Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size XS on mannequin, featuring a structured collar and open front design.

J Crew Black Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size XS

$15.99 $21.99

J Crew

Loft Navy Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium shown on model with long sleeves and V-neck, perfect for casual winter wear from Margaret’s.
Front view of Loft Navy Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium on mannequin, featuring a classic V-neck and long sleeves, ideal for layering.

Loft Navy Pre-Owned Top - Size Medium

$17.99

loft

Ann Taylor Black Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size Small worn by model, long sleeves and fitted silhouette, ideal for casual or winter wear.
Front view of Ann Taylor Black Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size Small on mannequin, showcasing its sleek, minimalist design and long sleeves.

Ann Taylor Black Solid Pre-Owned Top - Size Small

$14.99 $19.99

Ann Taylor

View all

Margaret's Shoes

Fabulous Shoes, Secondhand Prices

Shop By Style

Step Into Style: Shop Shoes

Explore gently used and new-with-tags shoes at Margaret’s Fine Consignments—from everyday comfort to standout designer heels, all at unbeatable consignment prices.

American Eagle Blue/Red Denim Pre-Owned New With Tags Sandals - Size 7

$19.99

american eagle

Frye Tan Textured Pre-Owned New With Tags Sandals - Size 7.5

$64.99

Frye

Bobs White Solid Pre-Owned Sneakers - Size 8.5 with rose gold eyelets and leopard print lining, available at Margaret's for casual daily wear.

Bobs White Solid Pre-Owned Sneakers - Size 8.5

$26.99 $34.99

Bobs

Coach Gold Solid Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 9.5 with cork wedge heel and metallic leather straps, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments.

Coach Gold Solid Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 9.5

$39.99 $47.99

Coach

Liz Claiborne Nude Logo Pre-Owned Sandals size 6.5 with gold-tone logo emblem and ankle strap, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments.
Top view of Liz Claiborne Nude Logo Pre-Owned Sandals size 6.5 featuring thong design and metallic logo detail, ideal for summer outfits.

Liz Claiborne Nude Logo Pre-Owned Sandals - Size 6.5

$22.99 $31.99

Liz Claiborne

Loeffler Randall White Holes Pre-Owned Slip On - Size 6/6.5 with perforated leather upper and espadrille sole, side view for Margaret’s Fine Consignments.

Loeffler Randall White Holes Pre-Owned Slip On - Size 6/6.5

$24.99 $32.99

Loeffler Randall

Ann Taylor Gold Sparkle Sandals - Size 7 with crisscross straps and shimmering finish, ideal for weddings or parties. Available at Margaret's.

Ann Taylor Gold Sparkle Sandals - Size 7

$19.99 $27.99

Ann Taylor

Charles David Black/White Polka Dot Pre-Owned Heel Size 9.5 with pointed toe and kitten heel, ideal for dressy occasions or vintage-inspired outfits.

Charles David Black/White Polka Dot Pre-Owned Heel - Size 9.5

$44.99

Charles David

Cole Haan White Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Heel - Size 8 featuring a classic block heel and pointed toe, ideal for formal or office wear.

Cole Haan White Solid Pre-Owned New With Tags Heel - Size 8

$44.99

Cole Haan

Dolce Vita White/Black Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Sneakers - Size 7.5 with gum soles and metallic heel accent, side view for casual fashion.

Dolce Vita White/Black Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Sneakers - Size 7.5

$29.99

Dolce Vita

Stuart Weitzman Black/Brown Lace Pre-Owned Heel - Size 7/7.5

$29.99

Stuart Weitzman

Lilana Green/blue Peacock Heel - Size 7.5 with bold peacock feather print and metallic green platform, available pre-owned at Margaret’s.

Lilana Green/blue Peacock Heel - Size 7.5

$24.99

Lilana

Privelage Pink/Teal/Blue Fringe Heel in Size 7.5 with bold ankle strap and vibrant fringe detail, pre-owned dress shoe for women.

Privelage Pink/Teal/Blue Fringe Heel - Size 7.5

$29.99

Privelage

Cole Haan Silver/Black Sparkle Heel - Size 7.5 with open toe and textured shimmer finish. Pre-owned dress shoe at Margaret’s Fine Consignments.

Cole Haan Silver/Black Sparkle Heel - Size 7.5

$29.99

Cole Haan

Cole Haan Fuschia Solid Heel - Size 9 with open toe and slingback strap, featuring suede finish and stiletto heel. Pre-owned at Margaret’s Fine Consignments.

Cole Haan Fuschia Solid Heel - Size 9

$44.99

Cole Haan

Louise et Cie Black Heel Size 8.5 with pony hair texture and ankle strap, available at Margaret's Fine Consignments. Elegant pointed-toe design.
Top view of Louise et Cie Black Heel Size 8.5 featuring gold buckle strap and sleek black pony hair finish, perfect for formal wear.

Louise et Cie Black Heel - Size 8.5

$30.99

Louise et Cie

View all

Margaret's Blog

The Beauty of Second Chances (in Fashion & Life)

View all