Shop Women's Dresses by Style
-
All Dresses
All Dresses
-
Floral Dresses
Floral Dresses
-
Fit & Flare Dresses
Fit & Flare Dresses
-
Maxi Dresses
Maxi Dresses
-
Boho Dresses
Boho Dresses
-
Babydoll Dresses
Babydoll Dresses
-
Sleeveless Dresses
Sleeveless Dresses
-
A-Line Dresses
A-Line Dresses
Shop Women's Tops by Style
-
All Tops
All Tops
-
Sleeveless
Sleeveless
-
Short Sleeve
Short Sleeve
-
Long Sleeve
Long Sleeve
-
Button Down
Button Down
-
Peplum
Peplum
-
Cami
-
Sweater
New Arrivals
-
Kate Spade Icarda Scalloped Ankle Strap Sandal Heels Size 6.5 M Ivory Nude Pre-OwnedKate Spade Icarda Scalloped Ankle Strap Sandal Heels Size 6.5 M Ivory Nude Pre-Owned- Regular price
-
$29.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$29.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
MICHAEL Michael Kors Simone Gold Glitter Ankle Strap Block Heel Sandals Size 5.5MICHAEL Michael Kors Simone Gold Glitter Ankle Strap Block Heel Sandals Size 5.5- Regular price
-
$27.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$27.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Sophia & Lee Clay Pointed Toe Stiletto Heels with Leaf Chain Embellishment Size 6Sophia & Lee Clay Pointed Toe Stiletto Heels with Leaf Chain Embellishment Size 6- Regular price
-
$34.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$34.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
ZARA Orange Twisted Knot Square Toe Block Heel Mules Sandals NWT Size 37ZARA Orange Twisted Knot Square Toe Block Heel Mules Sandals NWT Size 37- Regular price
-
$21.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
GUESS Lime Green Beaded Cork Wedge Platform Sandals Size 7GUESS Lime Green Beaded Cork Wedge Platform Sandals Size 7- Regular price
-
$29.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$29.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Ellen Tracy for Dillard's Brown Wool Blend Pencil Skirt Size 8Ellen Tracy for Dillard's Brown Wool Blend Pencil Skirt Size 8- Regular price
-
$24.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$24.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Gianni Bini Sequin Stripe Mini Skirt Faux Leather Trim Black & Silver Size MediumGianni Bini Sequin Stripe Mini Skirt Faux Leather Trim Black & Silver Size Medium- Regular price
-
$39.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$39.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Talbots Khaki Stretch Cotton Blend 5-Pocket Pencil Skirt Size 8Talbots Khaki Stretch Cotton Blend 5-Pocket Pencil Skirt Size 8- Regular price
-
$26.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$26.99
Add to cart Quick view

New With Tags — Without the Retail Price
Looking for brand-new clothing at a better price? At Margaret’s Fine Consignments, you’ll often find New With Tags (NWT) pieces — never worn, original tags attached — sold secondhand.
These are authentic, retail-quality items that simply never made it into someone’s regular rotation. Whether it’s boutique overstock, an unworn gift, or a closet clean-out find, our new with tags resale items give you the best of both worlds: brand-new condition and secondhand value.
When you buy NWT consignment, you’re not just saving money — you’re shopping sustainably. Choosing discounted brand-new clothing through resale keeps beautiful pieces in circulation and reduces fashion waste.
NEW WITH TAGS
-
ZARA Orange Twisted Knot Square Toe Block Heel Mules Sandals NWT Size 37ZARA Orange Twisted Knot Square Toe Block Heel Mules Sandals NWT Size 37- Regular price
-
$21.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Willi Smith Black Floral Lace Mini Pencil Skirt Size 6 NWTWilli Smith Black Floral Lace Mini Pencil Skirt Size 6 NWT- Regular price
-
$29.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$29.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
LOFT Asymmetrical Faux Wrap Mini Skirt Navy Blue Size 8 NWTLOFT Asymmetrical Faux Wrap Mini Skirt Navy Blue Size 8 NWT- Regular price
-
$34.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$34.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Express Ribbed Knit Bodycon Mini Skirt Rust Brown NWT Size SmallExpress Ribbed Knit Bodycon Mini Skirt Rust Brown NWT Size Small- Regular price
-
$24.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$24.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
St. John's Bay Classic Crafted Plaid Sleeveless Tunic Top Womens XL NWTSt. John's Bay Classic Crafted Plaid Sleeveless Tunic Top Womens XL NWT- Regular price
-
$19.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$19.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
J. McLaughlin Sleeveless Durham Top Navy Vineyard Path Print Size Large NWTJ. McLaughlin Sleeveless Durham Top Navy Vineyard Path Print Size Large NWT- Regular price
-
$59.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$59.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Michael Stars Navy Textured Mock Neck Sleeveless Top NWT Size LargeMichael Stars Navy Textured Mock Neck Sleeveless Top NWT Size Large- Regular price
-
$35.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$35.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Neiman Marcus Exclusive 100% Silk Sleeveless Tank Top Peach Coral Size Large NWTNeiman Marcus Exclusive 100% Silk Sleeveless Tank Top Peach Coral Size Large NWT- Regular price
-
$34.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$34.99
Add to cart Quick view
Shoes
-
Kate Spade Icarda Scalloped Ankle Strap Sandal Heels Size 6.5 M Ivory Nude Pre-OwnedKate Spade Icarda Scalloped Ankle Strap Sandal Heels Size 6.5 M Ivory Nude Pre-Owned- Regular price
-
$29.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$29.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
MICHAEL Michael Kors Simone Gold Glitter Ankle Strap Block Heel Sandals Size 5.5MICHAEL Michael Kors Simone Gold Glitter Ankle Strap Block Heel Sandals Size 5.5- Regular price
-
$27.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$27.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Sophia & Lee Clay Pointed Toe Stiletto Heels with Leaf Chain Embellishment Size 6Sophia & Lee Clay Pointed Toe Stiletto Heels with Leaf Chain Embellishment Size 6- Regular price
-
$34.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$34.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
ZARA Orange Twisted Knot Square Toe Block Heel Mules Sandals NWT Size 37ZARA Orange Twisted Knot Square Toe Block Heel Mules Sandals NWT Size 37- Regular price
-
$21.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
GUESS Lime Green Beaded Cork Wedge Platform Sandals Size 7GUESS Lime Green Beaded Cork Wedge Platform Sandals Size 7- Regular price
-
$29.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$29.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Tory Burch Orange Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Sandals - Size 10Tory Burch Orange Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Sandals - Size 10- Regular price
-
$49.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$49.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Magical Shoes White Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Sneakers - Size 9/9.5Magical Shoes White Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Sneakers - Size 9/9.5- Regular price
-
$49.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$49.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Get More Beauty Tan/Rainbow Beaded Pre-Owned Ladies Sandals - Size 9.5/10Get More Beauty Tan/Rainbow Beaded Pre-Owned Ladies Sandals - Size 9.5/10- Regular price
-
$24.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$24.99
Add to cart Quick view
Handbags
-
Patricia Nash Brown Woven Pre-Owned Ladies PursePatricia Nash Brown Woven Pre-Owned Ladies Purse- Regular price
-
$116.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$116.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Roxy Cream/Blue Fringe Pre-Owned Ladies Crossbody BagRoxy Cream/Blue Fringe Pre-Owned Ladies Crossbody Bag- Regular price
-
$21.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
No Brand Black Geometric Pre-Owned Ladies PurseNo Brand Black Geometric Pre-Owned Ladies Purse- Regular price
-
$34.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$34.99
Add to cart Quick view
-
Dooney & Bourke Tan Solid Pre-Owned Ladies PurseDooney & Bourke Tan Solid Pre-Owned Ladies Purse- Regular price
-
$84.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$84.99
Add to cart Quick view
Testimonials
The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable. The stock is excellent quality and there's always something new to catch the eye. It's a pleasure to shop there, and I can't recommend it enough.
I came in looking for a black dress to wear as maid of honor in my sister's wedding. I've lived in Lou for a year and somehow never checked out this store until today. Crazy. What an incredible gem! So many well-kept garments, and very helpful staff! I walked away with a stunning floor length black gown with beading and sequins on top for 22 dollars. I will be back. For literally anything. They have it all. Thank you for giving clothing a second chance at life! Oh also...if you are looking for any kind of derby attire including hats, jewelry, shoes, or dresses...thus is the place to go.
One of the most sophisticated thrift stores I've had the privilege to come across... very nice and crisp assorted clothing . I must add if a lady is looking for a derby item to wear I promise you that Margarets consignment will have your back 100 % xoxoxo
AuthorI love their consignment. I found a pair of size 10 Vionic wedge sandals, brand new, for $45. A total steal, as they were brand spanking new.
The staff is extremely nice.
Don't forget to visit upstairs, as well.
We'll visit this store every time we venture to Louisville.
I had a wonderful experience at Margaret’s! Such an eclectic mix of choices, and the lady who waited on us was super friendly! There was even a chair for my husband to sit in patiently! 🤣 Would recommend!



